Lights in the dark
by Alex_Petrini

Comment:
This is probably my favorite photograph in the challenge.
I love the vast amount of sky included. It is definitely a landscape in portrait orientation that works well. I even think the noise (high ISO I'm betting) works here.
Lovely photograph!
Bumping to a 9
Bump to a 10

journey
by Abra

Comment:
I keep coming back to this photo trying to figure out what to say.
I do like the silhouette of the cyclist, though I would have liked to had seen the entire bike... as it looks odd at first glance. Seeing the entire bike, spokes, wheels, frame, all of it would have enhanced this photograph, in my opinion, especially with it being a Black and White.

Cloverscape
by Melethia

Comment:
There is no real clear focus here, I see where there was an attempt, but it didn't quite make it there. Camera shake, I'm sure is the culprit.
Also, I don't think the composition works here. Perhaps a tighter crop to get rid of the distracting details of the half-cropped chair and porch, and maybe even a different point of exposure. It seems like you were trying to make the clovers the focus of the photo, yet the colors and brightness in the background overpower this.

wysiwyg
by herfotoman

Comment:
Not a photograph I find of much interest. Perhaps I'm missing the point of it? Can't tell if that's a fence or wall. And the dark vs light just doesn't work well (for my style).

Golden Hour
by DustDevil

Comment:
Love the sunburst coming through the photographer. Lovely warm colors and good use of silhouette.

Taughannock Falls
by posthumous

Comment:
The photo is a little too dark (for my liking) and I would have enjoyed seeing more of the waterfall. It seems the focus of this photograph should have been the waterfall, and this is a strange crop (IMO).

Last light on the alps
by jskotte

Comment:
Such interesting colors in this photograph! I LOVE the reds and pinks and purples and blue hues... they are gorgeous!
My only complaint is about the driftwood in the foreground. I would have liked to had seen that more in focus. I think the blur off it takes away from the beauty of this photograph. It's an interesting addition to it, so I would have enjoyed seeing it enhanced.
Nonetheless, I am bumping this photograph a couple points. In my TT for sure. :)

Somersby Falls
by dmsmith

Comment:
I love waterfalls, and it's on my list of things to photograph. I'm hoping to get out to a few different areas this fall, as WV is beautiful in the fall time. But, everywhere there is a waterfall is about 2-2.5 hours away from me! So, it'll be weekend trips, as I'll want to explore everything! lol.
Anyways... love the softness of the water. The slight mist that can be seen.
Overall, nice capture.
Bumping score.

Cypress in the Mist
by vawendy

Comment:
I really like how the one tree stands out from the treeline in the background. This is an interesting photograph that I enjoy looking at. Nice capture. Bumping score.

Burgess Falls
by MarkB

Comment:
Beautiful waterfall. But I'm not feeling the PP done here. It's a little too much detail for a photo in the leaves and rocks for my liking. But I would like to visit here! So for that, I'm bumping your score. Overall, a nice capture.