Like so many answers looking for questions...
by mefnj

Comment:
Like the title. The shot itself is very unique. I'm not sure if I like it or not... which really makes me take an even longer look... looking for the good and the bad. But, that's a good sign, because it means that I am very interested by it. Rather than putting "nice shot", and moving on, this is not a "meh" shot. it is more.
I like the darkness and brighter areas. The way the keys are placed makes for an inviting visual appearance.
After further review, I have found that not only do I like the placement of the keys, the lightness and darkness, but also the color conversion, the shadows, the noise... very well done. 9

Skeleton Keys
by sjhuls

Comment:
Lovely shot. Great detail, nice lighting. It has an "older" feel. I would actually hang this on my wall! Very well done.

Mountain Sunset
by giantmike

Comment:
Such a different, interesting idea! I LOVE this. It's brilliant.
Very well done.

Stretching towards the sun
by dogsandtrees

Comment:
A little off, in my opinion. The position of the flowers doesn't seem natural, the colors seem over saturated, or something, not exactly sure.
Also, the bright yellow background is a bit too bright. Just my thoughts on the shot.

Layers
by BrennanOB

Comment:
I love this shot. The peelings, the color, the lighting. The fact that it doesn't appear to be over processed. Everything about this shot is wonderful! One of my top picks, for sure.

The Collection
by NikonJeb

Comment:
This reminds me of when my husband and I went to an old Route 66 museum in Oklahoma. I loved it there, we had so much fun.
The only complaints I have is that the image looks somewhat distorted and the exposure seems to be a little dark. Also, the lights in the ceiling are somewhat distracting, perhaps cloning them out would have enhanced the shot. Still, I give this a 7

Memory Lane
by theluissales

Comment:
Beautiful black and white photo! Love the shine, the detail, the DOF. Very nicely done! 8

Cookbooks
by Bear_Music

Comment:
Love the crop of this, to make the wooden bookcase the only thing within the frame, actually creating a border with it. Very well done. The colors are nice, the detail is perfect. Good light. Very well shot and composed.

Lets make some noise
by ksierras

Comment:
Lovely guitars. Nice angle. Perhaps a different arrangement would have made this more appealing? Or a clean background, such as a black backdrop? The blinds and other guitars and stuff in the top left and bottom right corners are distracting to the shot. It takes away from the main subject.
Also looks like it could be a little sharper to improve overall quality.
These are just my opinions, so take them however you'd like.
I really do like the idea you've had, I just think with a few differences, it could have really stood out. Nice shot overall!

S H O T G L A S S E S
by Art Roflmao

Comment:
Love how this was done. At first, I thought to myself, how in the world did that actually stand. Then, I realized, this shot was rotated (or shot upside down).

We started a shot glass collection, but after moving 5 times in the last 2 years, most of them didn't make it. :(

Back to the picture.
Nice clean black background, makes the shot glasses stand out.
The lighting seems to cast a hard white reflection on some of the bottom shot glasses, which is somewhat distracting. But other than that, I don't see anything that could have been done much differently to improve this visually.