Remembering
by herfotoman

Comment:
It's tough to see what's going on here; what the photo is of and what the idea is.
Visually speaking, I'm not crazy about it. I don't find the tones very appealing, and I don't 'get' it.

The Thistle o’ Scotland
by Enlightened

Comment:
Nicely lit and composed, and I like the processing for the most part but might have done without the diagonal noise-like patterns. The overall feel is good, as are the tones.

Mulberry
by whiteroom

Comment:
I don't care for this one. The scene doesn't lend itself well enough to this lo-fi treatment in my opinion - strong shapes and patterns, usually on a large scale relative to the frame - that don't depend on detail being kept in the image work a lot better.

This is a photo that would depend on details to be effective.

Sentries
by jimmyn4

Comment:
The bold shapes vs. the fluffy clouds are a good contrast, but my favorite part of the photo is the left half. I don't know if you had the time to wait until some of the 'sentries' flew over and landed on that more barren tree, but if you had done and somehow composed to have the clouds behind that tree I think it would have improved this.

The other tree just has too much going on with the chopped-off wide branches and the moss and vines hanging from it, and also the leaves on the lower half. The one on the left is beautifully simple.

U N H U M A N
by Art Roflmao

Comment:
The dog is well framed between the posts, and the rest of the photo has just enough going on to make the whole thing work.

Thought balloon
by lei_73

Comment:
I like the overall atmosphere in this one, and the sharp but surrealistic vibe the girl and the bottom section of the photo have going on. I also like how the balloon string is interrupted by the light, like it's been burnt and it's about to fly away.

Over the river and through the woods...
by RyanW

Comment:
I like this one - the sort of enchanted, dark forest vibe comes through well. I like the fact that the kid on the left is wearing a vaguely red hood as well ;)

Emilie's Castle
by naomik

Comment:
Very surreal and colorful - I like the simplicity at first glance and the details that reveal themselves as you keep looking at it.

You will love Hogwarts!
by Neil

Comment:
Good choice of lens, it does make the architecture seem magical.

le grand voyage
by tanguera

Comment:
Beautifully done. Great concept and excellent editing, my favorite so far.