Leaf
by nathaliedoo

Comment:
Excellent shot, good lighting, fits the challenge well, good DOF... need I say more, unfortunately I will...

You could have used the clone tool here to take the small imperfection out of the water droplet, plus the little line next to the reflection in the water. This, to me, would have made this an amazing shot. Due to this I'm afraid I'll have to drop you down a point. Sorry [9]

Ice Cap
by BigMo

Comment:
I have looked at this shot a while as I'm not sure what I would have liked to change on it.

It's a great shot of the water and ice, the ripples in the water are nicely captured.

Maybe I would have liked to have seen more of the area?

A good shot [8]

Fountain.
by cimarron98

Comment:
I think there are two ways to do a photo like this, a long exposure to make the water look like silk or how you have done it with a short exposure to capture the water droplets.

I do think you have pulled this off well, but a faster shutter speed would have been good to get the water droplets really still.

In all, a good photo, nice DOF to get detail in from the front to the back. [7]

Clouds By Night
by marbo

Comment:
A different take on the water challenge. Wonder how many comments you get about it not being on topic...

A really good shot, the colours of the clouds are amazing and the stars are also nice and clear. 8

Water & Ice
by oskar

Comment:
Stunning, I love long exposure shots, this is a great example.

My only gripe is the snow covered grass in the front of the picture. I'd have liked that not there. (That's only my opinion though...)

A great shot. [10]

.... with a touch of Lemon and Lime
by agwright

Comment:
I like this photo, well done!

A good, clear and crisp close-up of the bubbles. Did you try this with ice? Would have liked to have seen that too.

A little touch of Unsharp mask would have brought out a little more details in the bubbles. [10]

Cleansing the Spirits
by MWitt

Comment:
Stunning shot, the clarity in the droplet is brilliant, I would have liked the red on the right to be a bit redder, apart from that brilliant. [10]

Out of Shape
by alanfreed

Comment:
LOL, not quite the idea for shapes but a funny photo otherwise. The person on the right of him isn't wearing a top either... lol... 7

Donut and Champagne - Concentric Shapes
by wetland

Comment:
I like this shot, my first view thought it was computer generate, but looking round the red circle I can see it's not a perfect circle. The use of negative space and how it's not in the centre of the picture it also good.

Murex Ramosus
by timmi

Comment:
Really like this, good use of lighting, like the blue on the right hand side.