trees won
by bjh0705

Comment:
Great motive! I think the colors may be a bit distracting here, for me this would look better in B&W. Still, great picture! 8

Life's a struggle
by northebound

Comment:
This is my favorite this challenge. Great job spotting this and then framing it so beautifully. I think maybe I'd prefer a less specific title, but I'm not reducing the score due to that. 9

Always with style
by gyaban

Comment:
Great picture, although I'm not sure if it really met the challenge...

Specular complementarity
by rio78

Comment:
Nicely executed, but isn't this theme a bit worn out?











EDIT: I realize my comment might have come off a bit harsh. I don't mean to detract from the picture itself, which is very well executed. It is just that I joined the site merely a few weeks ago, and from the few profiles and previous challenges I had looked through I felt I had already seen many of these shots, which was confirmed by a search for "glass".

By no means let me take away from your motivation, this is a great shot! I love the small droplets breaking up the symmetry, and the choice of colors and lighting is impeccable. There is a slight bulge in the color line seen through the water as well as the "horizon line", and there seems to be some refractions of a white edge around the colored background, but those are minor details and don't really detract that much from the picture.

So, to summarize (and of course IMVHO):
Execution: 8
Originality: 1

:)

Forkalien
by Neat

Comment:
What is it with forks and wine glasses on this site? :P

Let's do this
by hernan43

Comment:
I literally laughed out loud when I saw this! Perfect use of a triptych, the colors are great, and the title is awesome! If I should nit-pick on something it would be the slight difference in saturation on the left- and right hand side of the bottom picture, but that would just be stupid as it doesn't matter at all.

A 10 from me :)

A Dainty Sip
by KristinaG

Comment:
This would have been great for the complementary colors challenge!

Oriole against grey sky
by aznym

Comment:
Love the colors, but I think you could have cropped away some of that negative space...