Helping Hand
by Kelli

Comment:
This is a little underexposed for me and could also use some more contrast. I think working with the lighting would have provided you with a much stronger shot. Very cute though, the arm reaching behind her head is a nice touch.

A Peculiar Morning Indeed !
by Coley

Comment:
This is awesome. I just love this and it is my top pick for this challenge. This is just 100% perfectly executed.
The toast coming out of the oven is the best touch. 10

Penitent
by banmorn

Comment:
Great shot! I had an idea like this but never would have achieved it as well as you. This is very dramatic and well done.
I think a vertical shot that cut out the christmas trees would have been even more dramatic.
Awesome shot, I hope it does well for you. 7

Never Look Back
by bcrants

Comment:
Nice portrait that meets the challenge well, with some really nice lightening.
I think this would have done better if there was an answer to "Why is there a girl sitting in the middle of the road?". This way it appears fairly random...like "we have a road, we have a girl, lets do this". If you had provided a story for it (by placing some other object in the photo, or whatever) I think you would have resonated with the audience more strongly and it would have scored higher for me. Technically it is very sound. 6

Jive
by abuscemi

Comment:
Seriously sick shot! I love this.
It kind of stretches the boundary of what I would consider a portrait, but I am giving you the benefit of the doubt just because I love the feel of this image. The movement captured here is just awesome. 7

Reflecting on Christmas
by sammy_stecchino

Comment:
Its too funny that you can't actually really see the first girls reflection, but you can see the two girls that are blocked off by here. Gives the impression of two completely different worlds, rather than a reflection of the one. I really like that.
I very much dislike the pink color cast though. Its too strong for me.
I think I would have tried to make this shot a vertical one, cutting out the stuff on the right within the window and also cutting off the left half face of the guy.
Great shot. 6

She's all done shopping.
by sjhuls

Comment:
What an adorable pouting expression she has. And for once I think the border adds a nice touch.
The portrait comes off a bit too soft for me though, I think it needs just a bit more focus .6

Abu Omar Flaifil exhaust welding 079/6386589
by HighNooner

Comment:
I really like the editing and it is a very interesting photo with a lot to look at. But I am missing the "window shopping" aspect. Would have scored this one higher in a free study, it is very interesting. Just not right for this challenge in my opinionn 5

Just what I want for Christmas!!!
by LonnieD

Comment:
Awesome humor in this photograph, and meets the challenge very well. I do think the focus is a little soft. Some topaz or something like that would have been great for this photo. I also would have tried to get rid of some of that yellow color cast.
This picture made me smile :-) 6

Stars
by kannewurf

Comment:
Great framing and overall composition. I am loving the lighting shadows on those mannequins. 7