Getting Ready for the Museum
by tooter

Comment:
A perspective that hid the rooftops would help. I like the colors and the horizontal stripes.

Windmill in Snow
by davidw

Comment:
Nice image, I like the B&W treatment, but the horizon should be level in my judgement. A 7 though.

Needs Oil
by scarbrd

Comment:
Nice juxtaposition, and well executed. Lighting is soft, diagonal is good, blur of the in-line skate is right - 8!

Celing Fan
by NikonJeb

Comment:
I like this. The diagonals work, and the decay is effectively conveyed.

Right where he left them!
by awpollard

Comment:
Weird but effective - a 7 for me.

Out Of Steam
by ThingFish

Comment:
The locomotive portion of the image is cool, but the depth of field also allows the distractions of the houses to detract. The post processing is probably a little heavy as well, though I suspect that you were going for that look.

Classic Movie Time
by Tammer

Comment:
Technically excellent, but it does feel like a catalog photo rather than art which reduces the overall score for me.

The Busy Wharf
by odriew

Comment:
I think the original image wasn't really worthy of the effort put in to make it special. The vignetting effect (why is the top not included in the effect?) feels unnatural, and the focus is lacking. The framing would be better if the pier remains started in the lower left, then tailed off diagonally toward the upper right.

Oh. Again . . . ?
by Insomniac

Comment:
Great and humorous take on the challenge. Lighting is too harsh, though. And I think the guy is watching Letterman...

at the Old Gasworks
by franktheyank

Comment:
Nice machine, but too much processing for my taste.