Isaac with a fedora and a toy gun. Some ambient CFL light and additional light from a blue LED flashlight.
-Tripod, timer, manual mode
-RGB Curve
-Isolate Green channel to Grayscale
-Grayscale Curve
-A little local dodging and burning to darken sideburns and lighten neck
-Crop from top, right, and bottom
-Resize
-USM at 16%/64 dia.TH = 0
-USM at 88%/1.3 dia/TH = 5 (applied twice)
-SaveAs JPEG at quality 10/10 = 187KB
Statistics
Place: 102 out of 106 Avg (all users): 3.9832 Avg (commenters): 4.2500 Avg (participants): 4.0364 Avg (non-participants): 3.9597 Views since voting: 774 Views during voting: 365 Votes: 179 Comments: 11 Favorites: 0
I can't tell that there is a gun in this one or in the re-edit. Maybe a chromed gun would have given the image a completely different impression to the voters. It fits the challenge, can't dispute that about it.
Good concept and composition. I think you kind of missed on the lighting. There should be a high contrast between blacks and whites with plenty of shadows. I think you got the blacks and the darkness, but you are missing the light and the shadows.
Thanks -- based on this and some similar comments I re-edited it to try and improve it a bit:
This is a nice POV and mood. It's just a little too dark to tell what's going on. I can't tell if he's in front of a door, or an open field. I want this to work, I just literally can't see it.
Good concept and composition. I think you kind of missed on the lighting. There should be a high contrast between blacks and whites with plenty of shadows. I think you got the blacks and the darkness, but you are missing the light and the shadows.