Wow. What a challenge for me. Such a huge step outside my comfort zone. End result is a low-key, moody image that I hope will connect with folks. I'm proud of it, which is all I can ask.
Post-processing
Imported into LR3
Adjusted clarity (+50) and contrast (+35)
Generous denoise
Exported to Nik Silver Efex 2
Adjust brightness, contrast and structure sliders
Exported to Topaz Detail
Adjusted small, medium and large detail sliders (-1.00)
Exported back LR3
Adjusted exposure (-4.00)
Denoise
Resize for web
Statistics
Place: 26 out of 167 Avg (all users): 6.0244 Avg (commenters): 7.3636 Avg (participants): 6.1977 Avg (non-participants): 5.8333 Views since voting: 1115 Views during voting: 355 Votes: 164 Comments: 14 Favorites: 2 (view)
Very powerful. I like the 'simplified' pp'ing, and how the lighting off the door and the man mirror each other. Excellent balance and composition, except for that tilt...
I wouldn't know a piece of fine art if it fell out of the sky and hit me on the head, so I honestly don't know if this true to the genre or not. Irregardless, this is the coolest thing I've seen two thirds of the way through the voting. Nice work.
I love the editing on this. So dark and gloomy, but in an appealing way. I also love the contrast between the door and the person, the visual weight is on the door, which just further brings home the point you are trying to convey. 7
This could tell a story. It could be an example of social commentary of the day. Fine art? I'm not so sure. But as I struggle with so many of these images, I realize how subjective this whole subject is. I think I'll stick with my first gut reaction. 6 I like how the light above the roof of the doorway mimics the light on the guy's head and arms. Almost like the same shape as the doorway in miniature.
I really like the simplification of form in this. The contrast has removed much from the photo. Despite the fact that nearly all of the details that constitute the human form have been removed, we still instinctively know and feel.