Now this is what I was looking for! I could see a series of photos like this telling the story of a family that isn't there. Contemporary work needs intrigue and this certainly has it. My top pick so far. 9
7 - I like the feel, the mist, the colors, the perspective, the focal points - for me the elements of the picnic are 'off'. But that is just a personal perception thing, i.e.: apple and beer.. Up to 7 from 6.
Not fine art for me, but does have me wondering what's so perfect about this day, and what all that smoke is, and where all the people have gone. I see Stella beer, and a bite out of an apple, and some bread or something, and a shoe. No people. I think you want me to think they are making love somewhere. Okay, I will. Technically a tad dark, the elements we are meant to concentrate on are a little obscured, the existence of the smoke is probably unnecessary (you just wanted to use that smoke machine). A higher vantage point, looking down at the residue of the couple, may have really helped this. The mystery of b/w would have added to it, for me. I don't connect.
This shot has grown on me since my initial reaction. I love the fog and the brightness on the one side followed by the darker feel of the other. It really gives my eyes places to explore.
really nice shot, though I really this that this should be one shot in a series telling a longer story. I would try to darken the sky a tad more add some more mystery.
Hmmmm...a mystery. Where are the happy picnicking couple? Abducted by aliens? Did a murder most foul take place here? Or are they perhaps being passionate in the undergrowth? Whatever...it's a beautifully executed image with wonderful lighting.
As the stereotypical nerd, Frank's friends didn't believe him when he said he had a picnic date with a "smokin' hot babe". When the fire department arrived, all they found left of him was his pocket protector.
I had initially scored this an 8 but I have returned - it is better than that; such a story to be told here and the compositional elements are matched so well by your lighting and processing. Bumped to a 10. Special.
This is eerie. Half eaten apple, knocked over bottles makes me wonder what happened to the picnickers (is that a word?) Seems like they left in a hurry!