IMO I think I would have cropped out the bottom of the picture so that the clear reflections are what I focus on first...my eye first hits the bottom where it is murky then travels to the clear area...that area is much more appealing to me
Is this macro? Well, i'm sorry but not for me...The shot seems to be OOF too. Though, i like the colors at the reflection.
Sorry if i was rude, good luck!