This is really pretty! I love that I can see the snow falling. And the colors are just right - it would lack a little something if converted to pure black and white, I think. Very strong composition - and though it looks cold, it feels peaceful and comforting.
Genie, this is a very nice scene. The darkness, lack of color, and the falling snow all add to the feeling of this photo. I'd want to be inside by the fire with a cup of hot chocolate (or favorite adult beverage) :-)
I agree with Del, this is very mood-evoking except I can't really see the snow showers... maybe if I look really close. This is downright dreary. If that's what you were going for, well done!
I think the falling snow adds to the mood of the shot. I wouldn't change that. I don't care for all of the border but thats a personal choice not a detraction from your shot. Overall I think its captures the cold and dreariness of a dark winter's day very well.
I have an old shot that was taken in color but looked B&W, it was kind of cool...really like this location, but the snow falling is a little to streaked (shutter speed?) for me...it would make a great B&W shot without the snow falling...would really like to see this taken without the snow....super spot...