Shot in front of frosted glass; the glass was backlit with a clamplamp and a yellow gel, front lit with the on-cam flash diffused by a piece of paper. My adoring wife held the fishing line attached to the lemon, and sprayed water from the top.
I have a hard time focusing with the 50mm prime wide open, and never got the perfect image... would have preferred to have the drop in focus.
Statistics
Place: 158 out of 239 Avg (all users): 4.9286 Avg (commenters): 4.3333 Avg (participants): 4.7500 Avg (non-participants): 5.0196 Views since voting: 1103 Views during voting: 244 Votes: 154 Comments: 11 Favorites: 0
Camera Work/Technical: Reading through the comments, I'll just echo that focus is way off. I'll agree with Sarah that the aperture need not be so small.
Lighting: Nicely lit to produce an interesting graduation of white and yellow.
Composition/Content: The content is unoriginal and has been shot lots here. I do like your choice to shoot the yellow subject on a yellow background, but I think that also added to your focusing issues using autofocus.
My Opinion: Paired with the commonality of this subject on DPC (I've even shot one similar with an orange), the focus combination was enough to kill the score. I agree with the placement.
Thank you for the opportunity to provide a critique on your entry,
Eric
I like the composition of this pic, the subject is well placed and you have made some good use of the negative space. The graduated yellow background also works well.
I don't think you are going to be surprised to read my comment concerning the focus. Other people have identified this as a problem and you, yourself have said you had a hard time focusing. The image really needs to be very sharp to be effective and this really is not. With some images you can get away with a slightly soft focus, but not with this type of shot. One of the reasons you may have found it difficult to get everything really sharp is the aperture you have used. Using a 1.8 will make it very hard to get the whole subject in focus. Stopping down a few stops should have helped (say around F8). I know this would have affected the shutter speed, but an ISO adjustment could have helped that too.
I think your score was pretty much where I would expect it to be given the subject was not in focus.