Firstly, thanks to all those who commented on my photo - am relatively new here (in terms of posting, I guess) and my entry for this challenge was a) a bit of a last minute decision and b) I wanted a different take on the theme. I did expect a low score, but maybe not this low. Anyway, you live and learn.
So, blackbox and yospiff got the idea behind the image - and mstone to answer your question, I wanted to give the word a different interpretation - something not so obvious. I guess it got interpreted as being too abstract.
I think its a good shot. It is blown out way too much on the left though. But that's not why I am giving a low score. When I vote on challenges, I really take the Subject of the challenge into high consideration, as everyone should.
The challenge was "Evening" and I don't find anything about this shot to be categorized in "evening".
Even the title of the shot leads as far away to the challenge as the image itself.
I think it would have been better for you to submit this image for a different challenge and also work on the levels and curves if you do.
I am curious to hear why you submitted this particular shot for a "Evening Challenge"