Nice. Good elements. Nice lighting,The props in the back and the colours.The only nitpik is the focus is on the left side of the dish. I would have preferred the focus on the centre pieces in the salad. IMO 8
Not voting just commenting. Lighting is nice/soothing, focus is good. Would prefer if the entire bowl were in frame and the composition slightly less tight. Little bit of (red? yellow?) color would also add a bit of interest to all the greens.
excellent color and DOF, good lighting, I like the utensils in the background. crop at right and bottom is too tight IMO. the salad could have been arranged nicer
Technically correct , exposure, focus, saturation , contrast.6 a bit too washed out
Good composition. 6 lacks wow
Tells a story or creates a mood 5
Impact to the viewer 5
Relevance to the Challenge 8
Overall 6