This one is out of the box for me. Processing was actually quite simple. Exported from Capture One PRO.
In PSP XI:
Levels
Clarify
Time machine (cross processing)
Export to JPG.
(heck I didn't even sharpen this puppy)
Probably not a ribbon winner but I thought I would try something that was a bit outside my comfort zone. I guess if it doesn't score well its my own fault :)
Statistics
Place: 383 out of 468 Avg (all users): 5.1056 Avg (commenters): 5.7500 Avg (participants): 5.0187 Avg (non-participants): 5.3714 Views since voting: 747 Views during voting: 227 Votes: 142 Comments: 13 Favorites: 0
The irony here is great. If only there could have been someone standing there smoking, it would have really been awesome!
I like the composition of this. Because you didn't center it, the eye is drawn to the sign and are "comfortable" resting there. I also like the color tones and "style" of this shot. It is not "dpc friendly" but it does have a hip, modern, urban feeling to it.
As per your score, if it were in a "street signs" "urban life" or "irony" challenge, I suspect this would be a top scorer. Unfortunately, in a free study, the voters tend to go faster and have to be captured quickly (my opinion, of course). This does't grab you immediately, but it does hit you after a few seconds.
As far as "purpose," I think it is a pretty good commentary of society -- no matter how innocuous or "reasonable" a request is, someone, somewhere will find a way to rail against it. :)
Pretty grungy image here. Unfortunately I feel it lacks a strong subject. Perhaps using a flash and underexposing the background just a little might help the signs to stand out.
I am sorry to say this, but this image does nothing for me. I suppose if it were in an irony challenge then you could see something of it, but to me it lacks purpose. Again, I am sorry, and this is only my opinion and reaction to your photo. 5.