Greetings from the Critique Club -
I think you met the challenge here. The glass bowl is easily isolated by the orange. But overall the image leaves me a bit flat. Not really any wow power to bring in the higher votes.
I think the image could have been improved with some work on the orange. Cleaning up the background line and doing some work to minimize the spots could have made this a cleaner image. But going from your details it looks like you edited within the basic ruleset.
Not really much else I can add to this one. Hope something here helps.
Tim |