I like the inclusion of the railing in this shot. Without it the picture would lose a sense of character. Not a strong photo, but the b & w helps. Good work. 6
Nice picture. Meets the challenge. I think I would have liked this one more in color. The b&w seems to lose a lot of detail on this one. Focus looks good, lighting is a bit dark on the shore. 6 waltoml.
Once again a b/w actually impresses me. Including the element of the churning water was an excellent decision. You had a few different "planes" that fought against you here--the rail, the shoreline and the skyline. A slightly different angle may have helped. But overall, an excellent picture.