I got my son to sit on the kitchen floor in the morning light that streams through the side door. This was at 07:15. Not the greatest photo, he had just rolled out of bed and there I was, conning him (as the first one awake besides dad), to pose for a photo. changed to B&W, shadows/highlights, contrast, levels, some D&B, reduced noise, and USM.
That pattern on his right side of the face is from the light coming through the screen door and he doesn't have a black eye, just the way the shadows were.
He, he, first thing that came to mind, before reading your notes, is, "morning light!". The other thing that comes to mind is that the light is a bit too low, that is, I think I would try it with his head just a bit lower so that the light pattern would start closer to the hairline.
I think you got the "early morning look" quite nicely here, not only with the light, but also with his expression.
I like the portrait and light, my only suggestion would be to make a reflector, some buy a 5 in 1 reflector, you can use a a piece of foamcore(thick posterboard) and cover it in aluminum foil. You can then use that as fill light. In this case you would put it on the left side of the frame to put a little light in the shadows and naturally brighten up his eye in shadow. just a suggestion :)
Disturbing mood created with the light, and the expression matches it. That's a success, right? When everything contributes to the same feeling? It is in my book.
i like the details of the shadows on the left, but I think you could have left the right side darker because it is getting noisy and unnatural the way you have it. just boost the contrast a bit and see how tat looks
The shadows and highlights are well done here. However, I feel it is a little to evil and brooding to be used on the poor lad at that time of the morning! Perhaps on a more sinister subject this sort of light would work quite well. Note your comment from [user]Louis[/user], check his portfolio (namely his SPs) for usage of this sort of light.
I like the high contrast and black and white. I think you've used the window's natural light well to get that effect. Whereas this light shows the structure of his face well, I think the pattern of light on his face makes for a less well presented photo, particularly for a young subject. Unless the intent is to convey some less happy message, which might fit with the expression.