I quite like this shot. Seems your eye prefers a higher key image than mine but, this is a nice shot. I agree if the umbrella wasn't in the way the shot would be nicer but, that is a minor point to me.
I also think this is underrated. This was a fun image to view with lots of interesting things to explore. The exposure and composition were well done. Please tell me you are going to hang this one on your wall. I gave it a 9.
A nice refreshing approach to the challenge. Good job on the exposure, some of the brighter areas seem to just be on the verge of blowing out, but not bad at all. It's definitely a good choice of subject, IMO. I'm wondering though, if maybe it were not shot so 'straight on', from a little off to the side, more of an angle type thing, it could perhaps be a little more dynamic, maybe a little stronger impact, compositionally? Nice job though.