Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
The photo appears to be of onion rings, and while I like the concept and treatment, I find it to be too obscure and abstract to think in terms of smell. Also, the hightlight is way too bright and distracting.
Post actions
Now what could this be? I have no idea.
Post actions
Very cool! A creative way to shoot an onion; it's almost scary how close I feel to it. :)
Post actions
I'm not sure what this is. Your title isn't helping me much here... After looking at this many, many times I'm thinking the rings may be onions...? Please email me with more information and I'll adjust your score accordingly.
Post actions
woah, what is that? im lost....
Post actions
Took me awhile to figure out I was seeing onion rings...so it didn't readily suggest a smell to me. Creative shot though.
Post actions
I don't know what I'm looking at here. I'm guessing..these are rings of a lemon, orange? I don't recognize this. It's not an unattractive shot.
Post actions
Needs more DOF, and maybe more contrast, but great idea!
Post actions
They look like onion slices to me but I could be wrong.
Post actions
? Not getting it never mind the lack of focus and poor lighting
Post actions
Nice try. The macro is almost too close to be able to identify the onion. Back off a little to evoke more of the scent.
Post actions
good idea, but with almost nothing in focus its hard to tell its an onion.
Post actions
I get it, but not to inspiring to me.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
