A total lack of inspiration resulted in this photo. I had planned different kinds of situations but all resulted in very poor pictures. In the end I made a snapshot of my coffee container :(. I think it fits the challenge reasonable well although the photo itself isn't very exciting. A four or five would be sufficient ;).
Except for a little change of levels and in contrast I didn't do a lot of post-processing. As lens I used my EF 50mm f/1.8.
Statistics
Place: 53 out of 188 Avg (all users): 5.5551 Avg (commenters): 5.6364 Avg (participants): 5.4138 Avg (non-participants): 5.6429 Views since voting: 1210 Votes: 227 Comments: 14 Favorites: 1 (view)
Like several others, to me this looks more like dirt in a flower pot than coffee. The "rule of thirds" composition works well here, putting the center of interest at the coffee in the scoop. The shadows in that area are entirely black, with no details; this helps to frame the coffee in the scoop, making it stand out from the rest of the coffee, even though it looks much the same. The different textures of the focused and unfocused coffee adds interest. But not that much; in the end I agree with your own assessment: the photo lacks excitement. It needs some variety to create some impact; something as simple as a metal scoop would be beneficial.
Excellent compostition, lighting, color, aperture choice. I can just smell the coffee. The grinded beans smell much better compared to the end product.
Less accurate it would be but I think coffee beans insteaf of ground might work better here - certainly it's not immediately obvious that it's coffee and if I saw this outside of this challenge I'd assume it was mud in a terracotta flowerpot.
I like the composition very much, feels very balanced. DOF choice works well as does position of scoop.
The orange color of the container and the soft focus on the edges make this look more like a pot of dirt than a can of coffee. A deeper depth of field, with the entire surface of the coffee in focus, would help, and a different colored can, maybe black or metal, would help the setup. The composition is excellent.