I really can't believe this only scored 4.2. I read the comments tho, and I remember how psycho everyone here is about even the slightest tilt in horizons, and somehow nothing is ever sharp enough :) Sorry. It really is a gorgeous photo. I bet it is so incredibly striking at night!
0-3 met challenge = 3
0-2 creativity = 0
0-3 Lighting/Comp = 1
0-2 Viewer Appeal = 1
My Vote = 5
Seems a little tilted to me, this photo would have scored higher had the building been sharper.
Not bad but this shot could benefit from some straightening. I would also consider cropping it in a bit tighter. With the building on a complete horizontal and nothing but the building and water to look at this would look quite peaceful and serene.
I know this is basic edit rules, but this image suffers from converging verticals and a curved baseline. It suffers quite badly. The tonal range is also quite low, making the image a little dull.