nice golden sunset.
the border is a bit distracting though.
Maybe if you try a thick border line instead of such a thin one,
and just cut off the edge completely instead of "in the photo".
i vote you an 8
I like the monotone yellow colour of the image. It has a very peaceful feeling to it. It could use the following:
1. Make the horizon either lower or higher in the photo.
2. the yellow thin line around the image doesn't add anything to it, on the other hand it distracts from the subdued peaceful feeling of the image.
A very nice moody shot in duotone. Great choice of colour. 2 things bother me quite a lot here though.
1: A horizon running halfway through the frame rarely works, and it doesn't here... it looks unimaginative.
2: I really can't stand that border. I've never seen one of these borders that enhance a picture and just can't understand why people keep using them.
Score: 6
Score with above issues addressed: Probably 8