Wow! I am completely blown away by the faithfulness and doggedness of your artistic vision. And by the remarkable images you produce. I agree with Bucket that this is one of the more memorable shots in the whole DPC portfolio. I am saddened by the fact that voters here are so completely oblivious to the subtle charms of your work; but I feel fortunate to be able to view it here.
I don't know whether you were robbed or not...but I know this..if the voters had to walk through a gallery filled with the shots from the challenge they would find themselves bored by technically perfect renditions of the same sorts of things again and again..then they would come into a room with only one light, and it would be focussed on this shot..and many would stop and say...oh I didn't really see this one...and then they might start talking, thinking, and be surprised by how much they missed...
565th is frankly shocking and not particularly fathomable. the various elements of this shot work exceptionally well to create a surreal, bonkers highly charged image. there should be more people like you who totally goes against conformity to create images of originality, that are provoking and interesting and expertly done. i love this.
WAY over processed! From your title I'm guessing that is what you wanted but it had the potential for a great candid portrait without the plastic look.
What a wonderful doll! Is this available at stores only in your area? It looks so real, my daughter would love one. I like the lighting you've used in this, nice contrast and shadows. The dolls hand looks overexposed perhaps a little. Best of luck to you in the challenge.
Very artsy and unique. Since the fingers seem to be the brightest part my eyes tend to be drawn there, which I think is not what you want. Maybe tone down the highlights there (curves or burn tool) so the focal point is shifted more on the face.
This is a very surreal shot. The childs hand looks lit from within, like the scene from ET when he touches fingers with Ellliot. Along with the great expression on the childs face, gives this image a wonderfully cute and impish appeal. Very well done
Composition: 7 - The composition works very well. The only thing I'd change is to crop a little bit tighter on the right, maybe half way across the ear.
Technical: 5 - The high contrast works really well here to evoke a mood, but I feel too much neatimage or something has been applied, erradicating lots of the detail in the textures.
Creativity: 6 - A unique style child photo.
Appeal: 5 - Its definately attention grabbing, but its also quite creepy in a strange way, I'm not quite sure how to describe it.
my honest opinion: this has been so processed it looks hideous! I am really sorry to say that. when I saw the shot I thought, 'oh, that's a shot of a plastic doll' then on closer inspection, I realised it was a child...the use of Neat Image (?) has really destroyed this...I wish I could be positive, but I can't see any redeeming feature...
really cute, but oddly darkly ominous too. it feels very modernist as well, in addition to being creative, bit mad and thoroughly likeable. everything works; the high contrast, the whitening of the whites of the eyes, the big hit of noise reduction. i also like the close crop, the nice background, and even the border. it's all really effective and goes together to create a really diverse, interesting image. 10.