It's weird that you'd get hammered for not showing the full Beretta M92, but it wasn't shown in this shot in the movie. Seems a little unfair for such attention to detail to result in a lower score :\
Great set-up ... but All eyes are leading to the tip of that gun ... and it's not there. I'm wondering if the tip is orange or something and that's why it's left out. I'm guessing that will be the main complaint here by voters - If the entire subject was pushed to the right in the frame this would be right on! - rule of thirds and everything. As far as fixing the tip - that would require some spot photo editing .... - or in the case of basic editing ... some stray paint! :]
I think you should have taken this picture with higher aparture (e.g. F16), I am seeing the focus on the gun and not on the object, which I think the character her self.
I would have like to have seen it framed a little more to the left to include all of the gun and have the subject a bitmore right of center, well done.
My sister, for years, insisted I watch that movie. I did...I didn't like it and maybe I missed something. The music was good. I didn't understand the movie and I don't understand why you cropped out the end of the handgun. So...I'll say nice photo, pass on voting and leave it to better movie buffs then myself. Good luck...
The focus seemed to be on the pistol which has been cropped a little too much.. The right side of the photo looks really empty considering that the subject is looking to the left and is touching the left edge of the photo. 5 for me
very slick, I can't remember the depth of field it had in the movie but it may have been nice to have the face in focus too. Although if my sritique is coming down to the DoF I think you have done an excellent job on the photo and am just nitpicking. looks accurate and bumping up
This would be really good if the shot was moved over just a bit so you could see the barrel of the gun. The shot doesn't seem balanced without it. Otherwise good idea.
good, nice dof...why the cropped gun...either leave it all in or crop it a tad more...unless I am missing something and this is the way it was supposed to be...