Sorry, have never really been a fan of selective desat and especially when I don“t see it having a purpouse and that is the case for me here, to me it seems the selective desat has no purpouse and I am 99% sure I would have liked the color version or a plain b/w version much better. Not a bad shot though, gave it a 5.
This is my winner (I only pick one picture to give a 10 to). Most of the time, the B&W conversion with a spot of color is cheesy, but this picture does it well. I think it captures what summer progress is all about. I hope it does well and others agree this is the best. Good luck.
It's a cool photo in a way but I don't see why you chose the edit you did. Part of the 'farmers' shoes are missing and I think that takes away from the photo.
I'm not entirely sure, not being well-versed in agronomy, but I doubt the hay bales are rolled by one guy and a pitchfork. I could be wrong. Composition is quite nice, but I'd prefer it either all in color, or all in B&W.
Great selective desaturation, one of the best I've seen here in a long time! Composition is pretty good, I would suggest that you didn't crop / frame out the bottom of his boot.