Got mixed up with challenges... tee hee. Was submitting for the "Pick Two" challenge and realized I could only use high heels. So, I am glad I was still able to post to this challenge.
Halogen lighting from above.
Nikon D70s
Speedlight 800
cropped
Adjusted brightness +11
no other editing
First submission, not sure how detailed to get here.
Statistics
Place: 239 out of 271 Avg (all users): 4.1464 Avg (commenters): 4.0769 Avg (participants): 3.8713 Avg (non-participants): 4.3478 Views since voting: 818 Views during voting: 340 Votes: 239 Comments: 15 Favorites: 0
LOL'd at the idea, I don't think I'd put it together without the title. Try using lighting outside the onboard flash. Also, how about seeing the kitchen in the background. Looks like you're using a point and shoot (without much control on aperature), try stepping back a few paces and zooming in -- it'll give you that depth of field you long for! Gave you a six. Good effort!
A bit more attention and care in the presentation would enhance the impact. The rumpled, distracting background does not help, and there was clearly no attempt to deal with the edge of the table. the light is harsh and flat, giving little sense of depth or form. not to mention that the very idea you have depicted here is improbably unrealistic and unappetizing.
gross - oh, I get it now - what a creative idea for a composition- a little bit better focus and maybe purple jelly shoes and this would have worked more easily. The napkin behind is a little distracting just because of the symetry of the pattern and it not being straight or flat. I think that moving everything a little closer together would have helped bring this composition together
This is one of those set-ups that has only one function--meeting the challenge. While this is a photo of shoes, and there is some creativity behind the idea, ultimately, it is the type of shot that has no place outside the very narrow confines of this one challenge. This type of photograph doesn't seem to consider asthetic values at all. Why would someone actually want to view this photograph? I'm not asking this to be sarcastic. This is something every member should ask themselves before submitting to any challenge.