I like the photo overall, good compostition and colours but i feel the background and sky are a bit dull, i think it needs a bit more post editing. This is just my opinion though, i didnt vote but id say a 6 maybe a 7.
great image. I love the feel of the people in the boat as the sun dies down. Great job. Suggestions: If you were to have a boarder, I think it would have looked nicer in black. However, the photo would have been fine without it.
Nice capture! To make it an even better photo, I would need to get a sense of focus from the men on the boat, ie:watching the moonrise-the person taking the picture is distracting to the image for me.
i really like the composition following the thirds and the natural colours. The one guy un-silhouetted annoys me, especially as he seems to be taking a photo (?) which detracts from the tranquility of the scene. Other than that, it a beautiful image and fits challenge fine.