Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
i think the grays is too dark
Post actions
i think that this is a really good black and white picture
Post actions
Is that a rock in the in the lower left corner? Sorry, it bothers me that I don't know what it is.
Post actions
The maximum size for a photograph is 640px on one side; your long side is 480px. If this shot were submitted at full accepted size, I probably would have seen the goose sooner, and it would be much easier to give a fair score. At this size, however, it is hard to really evaluate.
Post actions
I like that you went b&w with this. I don't think it would have been as dramatic in color.
Post actions
The pictures good. But it's kind of hard to make out what it is.
Post actions
The goose was hard to find. Maybe this would have been better in color.
Post actions
Post actions
a bit too dark, hard to "see" the canadian goose unless you spend > 4s looking for it (which kind of defeats the purpose of the pic). 5/10
Post actions
Very cool imagery. The ripples in the water make it seem like the shot is OOF. I bit of a distraction. You did a great job and this is a nice shot.
Post actions
That's very pretty. I love how the black and white works so well with the goose. A border would have been neat too though.
Post actions
a little hard to see the bird, but a good idea.
Post actions
almost did not see goose, poor lighting,
Post actions
Hard to make out the goose when this is in B&W.
Post actions
The bird is a ltlle lost in the shadow and reflections.
Post actions
The duck has just enough 'camoflague' with the shadows so as not to dominate the subject of the image I think. The branch could be more dominant though so as to really seem to be covering the duck, Nice lines in the branches and textures in the water although it took a while for me to notice the rain, which could be more obvious.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
