Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
IMHO this is overprocessed. I never did quite get this kind of processing. Nothing personal, just my taste...
Post actions
Black on Black. Very nice.
Post actions
i love the swan, hate the shadow
Post actions
not too hip on your processing. makes it look fake.
Post actions
The swan is beautiful. The reflection, to this viewer, is a distraction due to its color.
Post actions
Not at all keen on the post processing.
Post actions
The swan is good. the rest is just too artificial.
Post actions
Wow. His reflection on the water is really neat!
Post actions
Post actions
The post processing here is a little yucky. Sorry, that is the best way I could describe it. It looks too processed.
Post actions
nice picture but seems a little too processed IMHO
Post actions
Post actions
I'm thinking the editing went too far. The lines outlining the swan and the shadow in the water make the image look unreal. <5>
Post actions
IMO this would have been stronger without the processing. Makes it look fake.
Post actions
I don't care for the cartoon look of the reflection. The swan is lovely and the coloration and detail is great. The black background shows off his red beak and the ilght on his back, but that reflection has me baffled. :~Z
Post actions
the reflection looks wrong. like you have burnt the entire background out.
Post actions
This is a worthy photo but diminished by the stark and (probably over processed) backgound and by the reflection. Nice commercial art and I can visualize it in an ad, but not here.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
