Composition Excellent use of the rule of thirds here. I love the 'emerging' from the water you have going on.
Color Good colors - hard to get a 'true water blue' in a pool type area. I like the darker colors here. The contrast is nice between the animal and the pool.
Lighting This shot seems a bit bright - what if you took brightness down a little bit? Or ... something to make the blacks blacker and keep the whites white?
Subject matter I love this shot for fauna! S/he's so cute! Absolutely meets the challenge.
Overall Great job. I don't think the score reflects the thought in this shot - and how cute it is!
Happy shooting!