Unfortunately your reflection in the glass wrecked the image. A lot of glare from the window in back of you, which also reflects in the glass. Stepping to the side, and shooting from another angle could have cleared up many of the problems with this picture.
I don't feel that the image conveys instantly recognizable decision. Actually what is happening is that I see a good picture of a window full of my favorite stuff, but I don't feel motivated to make the decision to select any one. The choices however were presented and the title makes it a more obvious candidate for the challenge. I give extra points on this attempt.
I feel like the decision should be clear without having to read the title. In this case, it isn't, so even though it's a nice picture in its own right, I don't think it meets the challenge well...