| Author | Thread | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/11/2003 09:37:07 AM			 | 
		
		Critique Club:
 
 Hi Rob. I'm glad I got given this one to critique, I gave it a 9 in the challenge. A very clever idea and very well composed, I liked this one as thumbnail and when I clicked the full image I wasn't disappointed. The colors are amazing, the lighting perfect and the challenge met fully. Rotational symmetry is also symmetry :-)
 
 Not much to criticise here really. There is a little graininess in the image but in my opinion it works here. The black hole is a little off-center but you can't really see it with the eye if you look casually at it. (I used a ruler he he).
 
 A very good image which you can be proud of, 13th place from 228 entries is excellent, and your best score yet, congratulations.
 
 Gary
  |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
 Comments Made During the Challenge   | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/06/2003 08:54:33 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/05/2003 12:14:09 PM			 | 
		
		| Interesting pic.  Pretty cool actually.  Looks like a light fixture to me.  The edges are pretty grainy.  Other than that it looks pretty good. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/03/2003 06:10:17 PM			 | 
		
		| The eclipsing object unfortunately seems to be slightly misaligned (or simply not big enough)... |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/03/2003 07:45:56 AM			 | 
		
		| Excellent. Perfect balance and symmetry. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/03/2003 07:10:08 AM			 | 
		
		| WOW I feel dizzy - lol.  Excellent image.  Love the lines, lighing and composition.  Very well done and GL in this weeks challenge. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/02/2003 06:34:21 PM			 | 
		
		| This looks very nice, I hope you included in the shot details what this is a picture of |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/01/2003 10:21:55 PM			 | 
		
		| Very cool picture.  Solar Eclipse effect. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/01/2003 10:15:21 PM			 | 
		
		| Endlessly fascinating with just as fascinating a title. Very nice abstract. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/01/2003 08:49:22 PM			 | 
		
		| Not certain what materials you used in your setup, but this is a fantastic shot!  Nearly flawless (there seems to be a slight flaw at the lower right portion of the black circle), and the lighting creates a great deal of interest.  --9 |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/01/2003 09:37:14 AM			 | 
		
		Wow, a bit noisy but very nice!!!
 
 A lamp shade? |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/01/2003 03:16:48 AM			 | 
		
		| Accomplishes making the ordinary look extraordinary. Nicely done. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
04/01/2003 01:24:15 AM			 | 
		
		| Wow.  Great lighting.  The lines and swirls are captivating. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
03/31/2003 11:59:43 PM			 | 
		
		| I like how the photo seems to pulsate on its own. Not really sure if that was intentional, but a simple yet powerful photo nonetheless. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
03/31/2003 09:12:16 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
03/31/2003 01:55:49 PM			 | 
		
		| Is this a lampshade?  What is this? |  
  | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
03/31/2003 01:31:48 PM			 | 
		
		| very, very clever and inovative!! |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
03/31/2003 01:10:33 PM			 | 
		
		| Beautiful....really pretty color. |  
  | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
03/31/2003 01:08:02 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
03/31/2003 12:39:34 PM			 | 
		
		 | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
03/31/2003 11:01:43 AM			 | 
		
		| What is this??  Can't wait to see when this is all over. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
03/31/2003 04:11:06 AM			 | 
		
		| What is this a shot of? It's very interesting anyway - really draws the eye. Meets the challenge well. 7. |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
03/31/2003 03:11:37 AM			 | 
		
		| Great job> I guess this is a lamp. whatever it is, you got the eyes |  
  | 
   Photographer found comment helpful. | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
03/31/2003 02:35:59 AM			 | 
		
		| ooooh ahhh how did you do this? |  
  | 
		
			| 
				
										
			 | 
			
03/31/2003 02:09:26 AM			 | 
		
		 | 
			Home -
			
Challenges -
			
Community -
			
League -
			
Photos -
			
Cameras -
			
Lenses -
			
Learn -
			
			
Help -
			
Terms of Use -
			
Privacy -
			
Top ^
		DPChallenge, and website content and design, Copyright © 2001-2025 Challenging Technologies, LLC.
		
All digital photo copyrights belong to the photographers and may not be used without permission.
		
Current Server Time: 11/03/2025 10:17:56 PM EST.