Something is just wrong with this picture. I'm no expert but it seems over over over sharpened on the boys face and the object item, the O is totally out of focus. In this situation and (it happens to me often) the focus was on the back wall. You shouldn't try to save a photo like this, its beyond saving. I don't mean to be mean either. So don't take me wrong, I have submitted pictures that are worse! :-( But I'm trying not to for the future. :-) A 5 for the effort though.
this looks like you took a picture off of a commercial on the tv... plus its not accidental.. he is meaning to hold up the bagel and you are meaning to take a picture of it
your "O" is a bit dark.. at least one of them... I feel some better lighting would have helped you.. I don't know if it fits the accidental part of the challenge.. So I'l vate like it does. I also feel you may have gone just a bit too far with neat image.. you were starting to loose alot of texture.. overall not bad. but dosn't stand out from the crowd either.