Composition - Well I think above and beyond everything, it was the composition part that dragged you down. There really isn't anything of interest here and you've done a great job portraying that. The one thing that I think you could've improved upon in this composition is having a little focal point. I find myself wanting to focus on the cigarette butt at the top of the frame. I think that could be an effective focal point for the viewers if placed in the right strategic spot, I'd go for the top right 3rd. But really the bigger problem is that there just isn't anything to see here of photographic interest.
Technical - I can't say the photo is poorly taken, it isn't. It isn't exceptionally well taken either though. The exposue is good, the DOF is right. It is pretty clear.
Overall - This photo is a bit lacking in subject matter. Maybe this photo is lacking in subject altogether. The voters were pretty harsh with this one and honestly I don't blame them. The best thing about this photo is definitely the clever title. The rest of it is pretty easy to come by. sorry I couldn't be of much assistance on this photo. Good luck in your future challenges. - Inspzil
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
