I would actually would have liked to see this shot in colour. I think the reflection from the cleaned up ice would have showed up much better. Great shot nonetheless. Well done!
I think the photos should work without the title, and I don't think this one stands on it's own. Not that it's a bad photo, the diagonal is a good element. The ice is perhaps a bit over-exposed. 5
Meets the challenge but doesn't seem very interesting, really don't know what to tell you that you could have done this differently, has the potential.