Okay, you said you'd like some feedback so I'll jump in.
I gave your photo a 4. I did so because I felt the subject wasn't interesting to me at all, and because I didn't like the composition or the lighting as well. To me, it seemed very cut off on the left. I didn't feel like there were any real impactful features of the shot...the colors seem pretty bland and lighting flat to me, the composition as stated above, and (I'm sorry) but I think the grass covered cat is not pretty at all.
It was in focus and the exposure seemed right, although perhaps just a shade dark.
I'm sorry I don't see the same thing in it as you do, but I suppose that's the way it works many times. If it makes you feel any better, I thought my 2004 shot should have scored better too :) !
Hope the feedback is helpful. I don't intend to offend, but wanted to answer why someone might score it low as I felt I did. |