Very nice imitation, just how do you get the egg to balance and how many did you break before you got it? :) A 9, the eggs in the bowl seem a bit fuzzy, I know DOF is in use but it seems like it goes from clear to fuzzy almost too quickly. Still a 9 though
Very nice! Brought a smile to my face to see my only ribbon shot entered in this challenge. I like the brown eggs and you didn't over sharpen like I did. Good luck in the challenge.
Pretty good, though there seems less fill light than the original. As a more or less straight copy I don't find it that interesting (nor did I think that of the original, really), but such was the challenge you have to get decent points.
I have to say that this is technically better than the original photo, the lighting in the original was too harsh and it was too sharpened. Its nice to see that you made it look better :)