Author Thread
Post actions
Well, so simple. Should have done better, but very well done, I liked this a lot
Post actions
I couldn't stop thinking about your setup, windering how on earth you achieved that shadow. And now you tell me it's painted? Okay, I fell for it. Great picture, keep them coming.
Post actions
Simple but so effective. Congratulations on your 14th finish.
Post actions
thought this would be in top 3, very creative.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Great creativity on this one, love the shot. I'm courious how you did this but good work. Simple and very effective way of deminstrating the challenge.
Post actions
nice illusion. the shadow is painted/overlaid on the BG?
Post actions
This is so marvellous! I can only guess that it is two photos, or had some other effect done. Good subject, composition, colour, lighting!
Post actions
Good idea! Good colors and subject. Really well done. Probably with a faster shot it colud be better (the pinweel is too fast!).
Post actions
WOW!! - great idea - did you paint the shadow.
Post actions
Excellent setup! Clever idea and perfectly excecuted.
Post actions
heh... this is conceptually excellent. I'd wish for a hair less blur in the rotation...
Post actions
Post actions
Very clever...Very simple and yet conveys the total concept of the challenge. Well Done.
Post actions
cool. the border is not a plus.
Post actions
Post actions
That is cool! Interesting idea...
Post actions
Post actions
I absolutely love this composition and the concept. I would love to know how you've done it - good luck
Post actions
Dude, how did you do this? I'm eager for voting to end to hear you explanations on this one. Great shot. The idea of wind is clear and well analyzed. The composition is fine, but I don't know what to think of the border. O well. 9.
Post actions
Post actions
Interesting idea. I'm wondering how you did it... Is the shadow really a cutout lying on the table? Effective image and clever take on the theme.
Post actions
Post actions
I really like this, its very clever, meets the challenge, but something seems to missing, I'm not sure what it is.
Post actions
Post actions
i like the contrast between the spinning wheel and the shadow, cool idea, and great composition as well.
Post actions
Cute concept! Well executed -- a nine.
Post actions
The border is distracting and not necessary. Otherwise I like this shot a lot.
Post actions
Very interesting image. I'll be looking forward to the explaination after the challenge. 9
Post actions
Clever. I'm going to have to guess that the 'shadow' is a paper cutout... I was thinking that maybe you had an external flash you fired, but then there's be a distinct image of the pinwheel too. I like the idea.
Post actions
it is an overall good phtograph except for the little bit of the actual shadow that you can see on the bottom right of the pict. 8
Post actions
Great idea! Guess you painted the shadow and then lit the scene well? (first thought was it was manipulated ....) Good job
Post actions
Post actions
Very clever. Simple but works well. IMO should get one of three ribbons
Post actions
Very interesting concept.
Post actions
Composition: 8, Technical: 9, Appeal: 6, Challenge: 7, Overall Calculated Average Score: 8
Post actions
Hmm...hand drawn shadow? Kudos for creativity! This is why I enjoy using this website. Quite inspiring :)
Post actions
cool, first i think flash, but is drawing
Post actions
I think the image would have had a more profound affect if you actually didn't give it such a direct title
Post actions
VERY creative and a good photo :)
Post actions
How did you do this? It looks like a graphic. I never would have guessed it was a photo. Very cool.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
