I didn't like how bright the background turned out. I also thought the cropping should concentrate more on the broken string. I think people would have known exactly what it was without the entire instrument in the photo. 5
Composition: 8, Would've liked to see the broken end of the string
Technical: 7, seems just a bit oof
Appeal: 6
Challenge: 8
Overall Calculated Average Score: 7
I'm sure there is an unwritten rule some place that there must be at least one guitar photo in each challenge :-) Nice DOF, the lines in the background are a bit distracting,