*Greetings from the Critique Club*
Initial impressions - I like the image, the colors and lighting are very nice.
Compositionally - I like the strength of that broken edge, and it's placement in the shot is nice. However, there seemed to me to be a bit of something lacking in defining the subject since only that one edge is visible.
Technically I think this image is very good. Your edge is very sharp, and the lighting is quite dynamic and pleasing. I think the texture of the background and striations of light along the glass really added to your image.
Overall, excellent challenge submission. Congrats on the solid score and high finish.
Julee |