How will you vote for Advertisements...

07/06/2004 06:34:38 PM · #1

Reason being, I borrowed an idea from a brochure that I saw this week. The problem with that is that it doesnt really involve a product. Though I was browsing the old one and saw a few without actual products. I just dont want to get voted low because there isnt an actual product. ARGH.

Tamron AF 18-250mm F/3.5-6.3 Di II LD Aspherical (IF) for Canon

07/06/2004 06:37:52 PM · #2

Is there ever a consistent answer to that question here at DPC? LOL There will be as many kinds of voting as there are voters!!

aaronb532

Canon EOS-20D

07/06/2004 06:40:39 PM · #3

"Your job is to photograph a product..."
Taken from the challenge details. I hate to say it, but if there is no product then it doesn't fit the challenge. Sorry. However, if it is the best photo I have ever seen I might still give it an average vote (5 or 6).

PS you do still have time to change it!

07/06/2004 06:42:21 PM · #4

Originally posted by aaronb532:

What if the "product" is an experience vs. a thing?

07/06/2004 06:50:05 PM · #5

And what if the "product" wasn't man made, but was exploited by man for profit. That would still consitute a product because it is being used to make money.

Example being The Beach. I know the beaches along New Jersey [most of them anyway] charge a fee just to go onto the beach. Man certainly didnt make it, but its an exploited, naturally made product.

Nikon AF-S DX Zoom-Nikkor 12-24mm f/4.0G IF-ED

07/06/2004 06:51:17 PM · #6

"Products" are sold every day that can't be seen or touched, but the commissions are real enough!

wwwavenger

07/06/2004 06:59:49 PM · #7

I can't wait til Advertising starts! I think I have a fantastic idea...

By my thinking, I'd look at the photo as if it were stuck in a magazine somewhere and see how well it moved me.

eirasi

Nikon D200

07/06/2004 07:02:07 PM · #8

I think product can be an idea or something you can do and is possible to make an advertisement about. In my opinion the product has not neccecarily to be anyting you can touch or is man made.

wwwavenger

07/06/2004 07:03:46 PM · #9

Oh, by the way this idea

was number 18 in the first advertising challenge.

Edit: 18, not 19

Message edited by author 2004-07-06 19:04:17.

07/06/2004 07:05:20 PM · #10

Well thank the lord some people are seeing it the way I am seeing it!

07/06/2004 07:07:29 PM · #11

Originally posted by jmlelii:

Well thank the lord some people are seeing it the way I am seeing it!

And those would be??????

StevePax

Canon PowerShot S50

07/06/2004 07:08:16 PM · #12

If you walk the edge on this challenge, I absolutely, 100%, guaranteed, promise you a low score. It may not come from me, it may not come from the other posters in this thread, but if you do not show your product blatantly, I promise you will not score above 5, even if your shot is otherwise perfect. You have been warned - that's the way things are around here. Please don't complain when your shot scores 4.5 that the voters "don't get it." You will be right in saying that, but I have warned you ahead of time that the voters don't get it.

Nikon AF-S NIKKOR 24-70mm f/2.8G ED

07/06/2004 07:10:41 PM · #13

Originally posted by StevePax:

Steve, I absolutely agree with you on the voting always being for the "obvious". But what do you think will be considered obvious? A physical object only? Or a little broader? Curious.

Dr.Confuser

Nikon D800

07/06/2004 07:11:49 PM · #14

Originally posted by StevePax:

In my heart, I am sure you're right. In my head, I hope you're wrong.

Sigma 28-105mm f/2.8-4.0 Aspherical for Canon

07/06/2004 07:14:33 PM · #15

Originally posted by StevePax:

If the above photo did that well, then I think I have a fairly good chance. Besides, I have plenty of other photos I could complain about, like my June Free study... someone told me I used too much editing in the computer, when all I did was adjust a curve. Well, you'll see for yourselves =)

Rooster

Canon EOS-400D Rebel XTi

07/06/2004 07:18:25 PM · #16

i think all the interpretations of the word 'product' are right on however, I think if you wanna win a ribbon, less interpretation & more obvious is the way to go!
Good luck everyone!

boomer

Canon EOS-300D Rebel

07/06/2004 07:19:25 PM · #17

Maybe it comes down to this. To some people, the "product" is the steak. To others, the "product" is the sizzle. Given the wording of the challenge, most DPC votes are likely to insist that the steak be in the picture. But others understand that the definition of "product" can definately be expanded.

Suppose, for example, you wanted to advertise a financial advisor who wants to help you have a great retirement investment program. For this challenge, would you have to take a picture of the advisor, or could you submit one of the South Sea island?

I took the challenge to create one great photo that could be used to advertise something. My "something" is more of the sizzle, and not quite the steak, so we'll see. It was fun thinking about the shot in any event.

StevePax

Canon PowerShot S50

07/06/2004 07:28:04 PM · #18

Originally posted by Kylie:

Originally posted by StevePax:
If you walk the edge on this challenge, I absolutely, 100%, guaranteed, promise you a low score. It may not come from me, it may not come from the other posters in this thread, but if you do not show your product blatantly, I promise you will not score above 5, even if your shot is otherwise perfect. You have been warned - that's the way things are around here. Please don't complain when your shot scores 4.5 that the voters "don't get it." You will be right in saying that, but I have warned you ahead of time that the voters don't get it.

Steve, I absolutely agree with you on the voting always being for the "obvious". But what do you think will be considered obvious? A physical object only? Or a little broader? Curious.

I wouldn't count on being able to do anything "broader" in any of the challenges and score high. I'm not saying don't do it - personally, I prefer the shots that push the limits, and I often score them well. However, you will not have a high final average.

eirasi

Nikon D200

Nikon AF-S DX Zoom-Nikkor 12-24mm f/4.0G IF-ED

07/06/2004 08:00:31 PM · #19

I'm so sad I just took my entry out of the advertisements challenge since I don't think it would get any good score since it is not a "real" product. :(

boomer

Canon EOS-300D Rebel

07/06/2004 08:02:17 PM · #20

Hey, put it back in! You really can't predict the score, you WILL get some feedback, and you just might do well. At the end of the day, so WHAT if you get a bad score? How does that change the rotation of the Earth around the Sun? Put it back in!!!

Edit: Oops, I see you posted the picture. A stunner, too. I wish you hadn't withdrawn it!

Message edited by author 2004-07-06 20:02:52.