DPChallenge: A Digital Photography Contest You are not logged in. (log in or register) 
 

DPChallenge Forums >> General Discussion >> Nominations for Best Commenters
Pages:  
Showing posts 26 - 42 of 42, (reverse)
AuthorThread
 08/12/2004 03:59:48 PM · #26
Originally posted by melismatica:


I nominate Kylie for a special award for taking the time and showing the interest to browse member portfolios and comment on non-challenge photos without being asked to.


How sweet; thank you, Melissa.
 08/12/2004 04:36:13 PM · #27
While scrolling through my "Recieved Comments" I noticed that Justine and Imagineer have been quite active with my shots, as well as with others. Just look at the number of comments Justine has made and that'll tell you something. And Imagineer has taken the time to comment on a few of my non-challenge shots as well. I love when people take the time to look through a portfolio and comment on something that strikes them. Unsolicited comments are the BEST!!! They're like an extra little prize in the Cracker Jack box that you just weren't expecting. So Hats off to all who take the time to do this. And a special thanks to Justine and Imagineer. :-)
 08/12/2004 05:15:47 PM · #28
Well I hate to be repetitive and too reciprocal but both you guys Kylie & Jenesis are always fulsome and forthcoming with your comments - and thanks for your most recent ones. Of course there's trusty, poetic Zeus, but Spanish Grease, JPR, Geewhy, e301, Melismatica, jpochard - among many others - are always very considered with their opinions. Time and thoughtfulness with comments are what makes this site so great.

One of my favourite comments has to be 'NO, NO, NO.' - I can't remember who by though... : )

Message edited by author 2004-08-12 17:55:05.
 08/12/2004 05:21:49 PM · #29
I haven't seen to many of his individual photo comments, but for an overall approach to evaluating photos and the photographer I really like dsidwell's work -- his now-rare photographer reviews were great.

Message edited by author 2004-08-12 17:31:11.
 08/12/2004 05:21:50 PM · #30
Originally posted by jenesis:
Unsolicited comments are the BEST!!! They're like an extra little prize in the Cracker Jack box that you just weren't expecting.


Unsolicited! That's the word I was looking for when I made this nomination, "I nominate Kylie for a special award for taking the time and showing the interest to browse member portfolios and comment on non-challenge photos without being asked to".
08/12/2004 05:27:03 PM · #31
Thanks to all who mentioned my critiques/comments. That helps keep me goin'.

And a SPECIAL note for his comments (kinda) for dhares interviews! What a great volunteer effort that is. Thanks Dan.
 08/12/2004 05:31:02 PM · #32
So many great people on here, It's hard to pick. So far, I'd say Kylie for sure, followed by Graphicfunk and Imagineer.
 08/12/2004 06:00:26 PM · #33
I do have to nominate KevinRiggs Why? Look Here-->Kev's Comments in Another Forum
 08/12/2004 06:15:18 PM · #34
Originally posted by frisca:
You have completely and totally misinterpreted what I have said. Let me try again: What I mean is if you have anything to say about your deleted comments, keep it to that thread or discuss it with the person who deleted her comments in the first place. Don't bring it into this thread. If you have anything else you'd like to discuss with me about my response to you in this thread, please PM me, otherwise please keep all posts on topic. Thank you.


Who said anything about deleted comments?

{sorry to all for be-laboring this but I truly did not say anything about deleted comments in this thread and do not deserve the above comment. If others can make posts jabbing at me, why can't I do the same? Please reply to me in PM if you must so we don't mess up this thread anymore then I already have. Again, sorry to all}

Message edited by author 2004-08-12 18:16:00.
 08/12/2004 06:16:12 PM · #35
Originally posted by VisiBlanco:
So many great people on here, It's hard to pick. So far, I'd say Kylie for sure, followed by Graphicfunk and Imagineer.


Thanks - but you just had great stuff, I just had to comment! I can't always do it, but I am trying to 1) comment a lot, even if not always well, and 2) give significantly higher scores when I can.
08/12/2004 06:16:58 PM · #36
Originally posted by dacrazyrn:
I do have to nominate KevinRiggs Why? Look Here-->Kev's Comments in Another Forum


Now that's a comment!!! The man is a blessing.
 08/12/2004 06:32:52 PM · #37
I haven't seen her nominated yet, but I sure think Kavey belongs on this list! :-)
 08/12/2004 06:37:09 PM · #38
Originally posted by boomer:
I haven't seen her nominated yet, but I sure think Kavey belongs on this list! :-)


Thanks Gary! I really enjoy commenting but I know most of my comments are shorter and not as insightful as many by some of those nominated here. Thanks though! Still I do really enjoy looking at images and sharing my thoughts about them.
08/12/2004 06:38:07 PM · #39
Originally posted by boomer:
I haven't seen her nominated yet, but I sure think Kavey belongs on this list! :-)


I would honestly second that. The comments she leaves are very nice, detailed and insightful.
 08/12/2004 07:37:00 PM · #40
::ponders what to say::

This must be one of the few times I can be found without much comment.

Many of you on this site (and others I frequent) are more artistically gifted or work harder at producing compelling and/or aesthecially pleasing work. I'm verbose and, hopefully, understandable in my evaluations. I try to balance some quick comments with some in-depth evaluations of the works that I see here. Sometimes I worry that my comments may destruct other's work down past the point where it can just be enjoyed for the expression it was/is to the artist. I hope that if I previously commented or comment in the future on your work it comes across as one who is trying to just give you a different view of your work. It in no ways means that I don't respect what you've done; its just my opinion. My hope is that the attention encourages you to keep on producing whatever kind of work you like to shoot whether its your bread-n-butter shot or if you're just getting into a particular type of photography.

As one of the nominated, the nominations mean a lot.

Thanks,

Kev
 08/12/2004 07:41:16 PM · #41
Originally posted by KevinRiggs:
::ponders what to say::

This must be one of the few times I can be found without much comment.

Many of you on this site (and others I frequent) are more artistically gifted or work harder at producing compelling and/or aesthecially pleasing work. I'm verbose and, hopefully, understandable in my evaluations. I try to balance some quick comments with some in-depth evaluations of the works that I see here. Sometimes I worry that my comments may destruct other's work down past the point where it can just be enjoyed for the expression it was/is to the artist. I hope that if I previously commented or comment in the future on your work it comes across as one who is trying to just give you a different view of your work. It in no ways means that I don't respect what you've done; its just my opinion. My hope is that the attention encourages you to keep on producing whatever kind of work you like to shoot whether its your bread-n-butter shot or if you're just getting into a particular type of photography.

As one of the nominated, the nominations mean a lot.

Thanks,

Kev


I think you can rest assured that you are most appreciated! Isn't this a great place to be, especially when we are helping each other in positive ways?
 08/13/2004 11:00:00 AM · #42
Originally posted by KevinRiggs:
::ponders what to say::

This must be one of the few times I can be found without much comment.

Many of you on this site (and others I frequent) are more artistically gifted or work harder at producing compelling and/or aesthecially pleasing work. I'm verbose and, hopefully, understandable in my evaluations. I try to balance some quick comments with some in-depth evaluations of the works that I see here. Sometimes I worry that my comments may destruct other's work down past the point where it can just be enjoyed for the expression it was/is to the artist. I hope that if I previously commented or comment in the future on your work it comes across as one who is trying to just give you a different view of your work. It in no ways means that I don't respect what you've done; its just my opinion. My hope is that the attention encourages you to keep on producing whatever kind of work you like to shoot whether its your bread-n-butter shot or if you're just getting into a particular type of photography.

As one of the nominated, the nominations mean a lot.

Thanks,

Kev


Hi Kev,

Just wanted you to know that your comments are excellent, and very, very helpful. I have never figured out how to reciprocate. Take care,

Ursula
Pages:  
Current Server Time: 11/13/2025 10:37:39 PM

Please log in or register to post to the forums.


Home - Challenges - Community - League - Photos - Cameras - Lenses - Learn - Help - Terms of Use - Privacy - Top ^
DPChallenge, and website content and design, Copyright © 2001-2025 Challenging Technologies, LLC.
All digital photo copyrights belong to the photographers and may not be used without permission.
Current Server Time: 11/13/2025 10:37:40 PM EST.