Advanced editing question - DPChallenge Forums

Canon EF 17-40mm f/4.0L USM

10/05/2008 04:54:30 AM · #1

Reading the active poll I have the tenptaption of apply as first time a texture to my entry. This means that I can take every image that I want and apply it to my image or only in a spot of my image? the image must have some particular characteristic?

Judi

Canon EOS-5D Mark III

10/05/2008 07:16:15 AM · #2

Be very careful. What one SC member may think as adding a new element.....another may not. To be sure, contact SC and get them to vote on it. Allow as much time as possible. I have tried to do this before without adding a new element but it was rejected....I doubt it was voted on though.

Canon EF 24-70mm f/2.8L USM

10/05/2008 02:36:28 PM · #3

Originally posted by Judi:

Infact I have opened a ticket with SC but I doubt that i can have an answer before that in italy be night......

violinist123

Canon EOS-6D

10/05/2008 02:56:24 PM · #4

Don't do it. My sole rules DQ was for using a texture. I sent in 4 quotes from SC in the forums saying it was legal, to no avail. Do not do it, you can not rely on any precedent regarding it.

BeeCee

Nikon D40

Nikon AF-S DX Zoom-Nikkor 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 ED

10/05/2008 03:02:12 PM · #5

I don't believe textures are, at this time, legal in advanced.

"You must:
create your entry from 1-10 captures of a single scene (defined as a scene whose composition/framing does not change). All captures used must be shot within the challenge submission dates."

10/05/2008 03:02:30 PM · #6

Originally posted by violinist123:

Don't do it. My sole rules DQ was for using a texture. I sent in 4 quotes from SC in the forums saying it was legal, to no avail. Do not do it, you can not rely on any precedent regarding it.

the open poll on the texture show that the problem exists and probably there isn't an unanimous position in the SC. As personal opinion I think that the texture must go out from the advanced editng and my vote in the current poll is in this direction. honestly without that poll I would have never thought about being able to use texture.

Nikon AF-S DX Zoom-Nikkor 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 ED

10/05/2008 03:03:50 PM · #7

Originally posted by BeeCee:

yes but a texture is an extern image that you use as "background" for some special effect on the image.

BeeCee

Nikon D40

10/05/2008 03:24:17 PM · #8

Originally posted by Rino63:

Originally posted by BeeCee:
I don't believe textures are, at this time, legal in advanced.

"You must:
create your entry from 1-10 captures of a single scene (defined as a scene whose composition/framing does not change). All captures used must be shot within the challenge submission dates."

yes but a texture is an extern image that you use as "background" for some special effect on the image.

I'm aware of that. And I still don't see anything in the rules that would allow it.
Am I missing something?

Nikon AF-S DX Zoom-Nikkor 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 ED

10/05/2008 03:42:54 PM · #9

Originally posted by BeeCee:

Originally posted by Rino63:

Originally posted by BeeCee:
I don't believe textures are, at this time, legal in advanced.

"You must:
create your entry from 1-10 captures of a single scene (defined as a scene whose composition/framing does not change). All captures used must be shot within the challenge submission dates."

yes but a texture is an extern image that you use as "background" for some special effect on the image.

I'm aware of that. And I still don't see anything in the rules that would allow it.
Am I missing something?

probably isn't allowed but actually not forbidden. considering that every image could be considered as a texture probably this is the reason for the poll. the actual result for the texture is that the dpc members don't like the use of textures in the images hence I think that we'll have new advanced editing rules in the future.

BeeCee

Nikon D40

10/05/2008 03:48:21 PM · #10

I may be wrong but I think, as the rules stand now, textures would be illegal, since you're combining two different photos, but many members would like to see them allowed since they're used more like other legal filters than actual photos. Seems like those polled don't agree, though.

cpanaioti

Canon EOS-40D

Canon EF 70-300mm f/4.5-5.6 DO IS USM

10/05/2008 03:51:47 PM · #11

The current rules allow you to combine several images depicting the same scene with the same composition with slight variances due to wind.

Since a texture, as you describe it, would be a separate image it would not be allowed.
(my interpretation, which has been confirmed in other threads) We'll see what SC says in response to your ticket.

10/05/2008 03:59:33 PM · #12

periodically we come back on the editing rules but really we have always challenge in advanced or basic editing, only many rarely minimal or expert editing. probably is only my idea but the new "time lapse" editing have few fans. i don't remember last expert editing challenge.