Comment Feedback - DPChallenge Forums

08/03/2003 11:17:03 AM · #1

I have just begun to comment and vote on the garden challenge. I am asking that the people that I have given comments to, PM me to let me know what they think of my comments. DO NOT divulge which picture it is. For each response I get to this request I will make a comment on an additional picture.

08/03/2003 02:29:33 PM · #2

So far so good, 1 response and now one more comment. :<)

Ah hell, I went ahead and gave two for good measure. :<)

Message edited by author 2003-08-03 14:35:02.

08/03/2003 08:11:09 PM · #3

Hey another response so now back to the voting and at least one more comment.

08/04/2003 10:37:56 AM · #4

I finally made it to 20% with comments on about 60% of those. IMO the entries are generally above average, with some of them being fabulous.

My original request still holds, so I am waiting for some feedback.

Hey this is cool, I got my own little thread going. :<)

Canon EF 24-105mm f/4.0L IS

08/04/2003 08:28:50 PM · #5

I just got another response from a generous photographer that I gave a comment to earlier.

I guess you know what that means. I just made another comment while voting on the garden challenge.

timmi

Canon EOS-5D Mark II

08/05/2003 01:18:35 AM · #6

autool, is this your private thread or what LOL :-))) I like what you have going here. BTW, I got an e-mail from you thanking me for ading you to my favorite photographers list. You are wlecome, it's my pleasure. I also like that you participate a lot in the forum discussions.

Canon EF 70-200mm f/4.0L USM

08/05/2003 10:13:34 AM · #7

timmi,
I am more or less over the hill around here so talking to myself is acceptable.
:<)

I just dropped a couple more comments in the garden challenge, of course that was due to a wonderful response from one of those that I gave a comment to earlier.

Keep them coming folks! :<)

RHoldenSr

Canon EOS-5D

08/05/2003 10:41:25 AM · #8

This has to the first thread that I have seen where a member is carrying on with the entire conversation :)
Good job Autool!
Maybe I will try the same to increase and improve my critiqueing :)
It helps to get feedback.
I think it would be flattering for you? Lets as jmsetzler :) LOL

Calvus

08/05/2003 10:53:15 AM · #9

Robin,
Thanks, I'll take that as a compliment. :<)

Dick

08/05/2003 11:12:32 AM · #10

Well, I just got back from giving another one. I hope it was a forum reader so they have me do another. :<)

joanns

Fujifilm FinePix S5 Pro

08/05/2003 11:25:34 AM · #11

autool, I did receive a comment from you and I cannot comment on your comment without revealing my photo but, I can tell you this much, it was very much appreciated and helpful.

08/05/2003 11:32:23 AM · #12

Originally posted by joanns:

autool, I did receive a comment from you and I cannot comment on your comment without revealing my photo but, I can tell you this much, it was very much appreciated and helpful.

Hey, that's good enough for me.

I'm off to do another one. :<)

Oh by the way, I know I gave some comments that weren't all rosey and happy. If you PM me all you have to say is, "I don't agree with your lousey comment on my picture." That won't give up anything up about which pic it was, and we will go from there. :<)

Message edited by author 2003-08-05 11:46:37.

JC_Homola

Canon EF 135mm f/2.0L USM

08/05/2003 12:27:55 PM · #13

I'll be one of those writing you after the voting closes... To discuss a little more in depth how you viewed my image.
Thanks....

Sigma 70-200 /2.8 APO EX DG Macro HSM II

08/05/2003 12:54:27 PM · #14

Originally posted by sslickk:

I'll be one of those writing you after the voting closes... To discuss a little more in depth how you viewed my image.
Thanks....

Looking forward to it. :<)

sulamk

Canon EOS-60D

08/05/2003 01:33:15 PM · #15

thanks for your comment!