OK - So whats the diff? - DPChallenge Forums

Canon EF-S 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6 II

02/10/2006 09:31:51 AM · #1

This can't be fair after all thats been debated!

So, what the only difference is that the score for the GIS_boy's image was really high and it might piss off most of the voters, so we aren't going to dq it?

Looks like a major element to me when compared to nsbca7's image!!!

Cyndane

Canon EOS-350D Rebel XT

02/10/2006 09:34:19 AM · #2

What major element?

"Originally I had used the clone tool to substantially alter my shadow into the winged crusader. My wife in her wisdom told me I would be disqualified as you are only allowed minor cloning so I had to approach the problem from another angle.

I took 4 meters of her black backdrop material and made myself a shadow. I placed the material on the driveway and then went back to the camera to take the shot. I had to run down steps and get in position for the exposure - Buy the end of the shot I was beat!"

Message edited by author 2006-02-10 09:34:31.

cpanaioti

Canon EOS-40D

Canon EF 70-300mm f/4.5-5.6 DO IS USM

02/10/2006 10:06:39 AM · #3

The caped crusader image uses a prop, not photoshop.

karmat

Apple iPhone 7

Canon EF 70-200mm f/4.0L USM

02/10/2006 10:18:55 AM · #4

Having seen the original, I can assure you that it looked almost exactly like the submitted version. The only post work done would have been with colors/contrast etc. What he explains in the photographer's notes field is dead on with what we saw in the original.

For dpc, sometimes it is possible, and almost always desireable, to get your effect before you push the shutter. Just makes life easier, ya know? ;)

Fujifilm XF 55-200mm f/3.5-4.8 R LM OIS

02/10/2006 10:38:28 AM · #5

Oops, my bad!

I read down to the line where it said "Okay, this is starting to sound like an Oscars speech.."

I apologize! It was early and I should have read the whole thing. I guess I just got all wrapped up in the latest debate. Sorry.

Martin

Prof_Fate

02/10/2006 11:06:21 AM · #6

the light from the garage HAD to fall on the material as it lay on the driveway - so how much fixing had to be done to make it look this black and light free?

perhaps the photog is a wiz at set up, but I would love to see the original to know for myself how much cloning or other work was done to it.

ursula

Fujifilm X-T2

02/10/2006 11:27:31 AM · #7

Originally posted by Prof_Fate:

Very little work. If you look at the submitted version, you can see the patterning of light/shadow. It doesn't show much on the black fabric, not like on the floor where it makes a very distinct pattern. The photog did an excellent job of setting this up.

Cutter

Nikon D700

Nikon AF-S DX Zoom-Nikkor 17-55mm f/2.8G IF-ED

02/10/2006 11:32:18 AM · #8

where is the little pitchfork character posted sometimes....

No big deal Mwitt. easy to skim thru. I just think we need to

a. Clarify rules
b. Still give people the benefit of the doubt.
c. Have fun with this all..

marcellieb

Canon EOS-400D Rebel XTi

Canon EF 50mm f/1.8 II

02/10/2006 11:33:37 AM · #9

LOL - Mwitt - looks to me like you realy stepped in that one. By the way - Cyndane - love your work. Again my question - How in the hell do you guys come up with these ideas? Maybe there is a lack in my education. Don't get me wrong - I can take the shot, but everything must be there - I just don't get the ideas for making the set-up. I am working on it though.

karmat

Apple iPhone 7

Canon EF 70-200mm f/4.0L USM

02/10/2006 12:08:27 PM · #10

Originally posted by Prof_Fate:

from his notes
PS Editing:
Levels, (entire Image)
20% Saturation, (Entire Image)
Bit of Dodging on the shadow, (you could see the grated roller door's shadows on it)
Little Clone tool around the ears,
Resized,
USM,
Saved for web, (73%).

In my "recreation" of it, levels did most of the work. a "bit" of dodging, was just that, a bit. Percentage? want a number? I have no way to quantify that, but it wasn't much. The clone tool around the ear could be counted by pixels.

Now, my experience around here tells me that I have probably just set myself up to be in the middle of a conflict, so please know, I am simply posting this as the question keeps coming up.

If the photog wants to post the original, that is his perogative. If not, that is up to him as well.

Prof Fate, did you get my response to your ticket (I only ask because I am notorious for not pressing the wrong button and not sending the response. ;) )

Message edited by author 2006-02-10 12:22:23.

02/10/2006 12:58:00 PM · #11

Originally posted by Cutter:

Or remove the rules altogether!