Rule of thirds outtakes - DPChallenge Forums

09/30/2005 08:27:40 PM · #26

Originally posted by banmorn:

Entered:

Alternate:

Hmmmmm, I like your entry best. I rated it pretty high when voting. :)

09/30/2005 08:29:23 PM · #27

Originally posted by GinaRothfels:

What I entered

What I should have entered

I never really expected it to do well, but I like it. Still I should have known better.

The harsh contrast of your entry wasn't as appealing to me as your outtake. Good catches though.

Message edited by author 2005-09-30 20:29:52.

09/30/2005 08:31:24 PM · #28

Originally posted by elee3009:

While the debate rages on, would appreciate some feedback as well. Had a difficult time choosing which to enter.

Initially thought this:
null

but entered this instead:
//www.dpchallenge.com/image.php?IMAGE_ID=233819

Eileen

Both pics are fantastic, the pond drew my interest longer, but hard to say what it would have done in the challenge. Great shots.

09/30/2005 08:33:10 PM · #29

Originally posted by barndog:

Wow can you believe it! My outtake was almost the same as the blue but I changed my mind the day of rollover.

My entry:

My Outtake:

I'd have gone with the outtake. Absolutely beautiful. Both pics are great though.

I wish I'd gone with my outtake.....live and learn.

09/30/2005 08:35:39 PM · #30

Originally posted by Sherri1209:

I like the one you entered. On my screen the other one looks a bit over-sharpen, but I know that also depends on the resolution of the monitor. The first one is lovely.

Entered:

Outtake:

I think I'd have entered the outtake. But then, I'm still learning what to enter and what not to.

PhotoRyno

Canon EOS-5D

09/30/2005 09:23:58 PM · #31

Did not enter anything

09/30/2005 09:35:56 PM · #32

Sherri

I prefer the the shot of the goat. The horse and rider is very awkward because the girl is bouncing badly and looks out of control and the horses nose is cut off. Just not as balanced a picture as the goat in my opinion. Also the horse and rider looks a bit over saturated and a bit soft? Hope this helps

Message edited by author 2005-09-30 21:36:55.

09/30/2005 09:38:55 PM · #33

I prefer the third shot of the balloons, the one with the flame. The one you entered had too much blow out on the left side of the frame for my liking.

Message edited by author 2005-09-30 21:40:00.

09/30/2005 09:41:52 PM · #34

Barndog

I also prefer the shot of the bird, althought he one you entered was nice and bright with the color, I think I would have scored the shot of the bird higher

09/30/2005 09:43:31 PM · #35

Banmorn

I also prefer the one you entered of the three flowers. Great shot.