Summer Fashion
by Marika

Comment:
I've decided to comment on every shot in this challenge, since I'm sitting at 1 comments, and I'd rather try and take a positive approach to this rather than simply whining about my score:

A nicely simple and on-the-mark image. Rendered a little too plastic for MY tastes, but such are the ways sometimes.

Masquerade
by OzShadow

Comment:
I've decided to comment on every shot in this challenge, since I'm sitting at 1 comments, and I'd rather try and take a positive approach to this rather than simply whining about my score:

I don't know exactly why, but this image disturbs me slightly. It's got a dark humor to it, but the look of the model, that gaze, is frightening. I think less fashion here than I do Human Psychosis. A fantastically poignant image on its own, but for the challenge, it misses the mark for me.

Love conquers all
by purpleflutterby13

Comment:
I've decided to comment on every shot in this challenge, since I'm sitting at 1 comments, and I'd rather try and take a positive approach to this rather than simply whining about my score:

A unique shot, with a subtle message. I especially like that you kept the small amount of graffiti on the tank in the shot. A little too overly smoothed out for my tastes, but the message remains.

Young Doll
by vanast123

Comment:
I've decided to comment on every shot in this challenge, since I'm sitting at 1 comments, and I'd rather try and take a positive approach to this rather than simply whining about my score:

Almost disturbing, and could use a little work in contrast I think.

Asian Model
by amateurboi

Comment:
I've decided to comment on every shot in this challenge, since I'm sitting at 1 comments, and I'd rather try and take a positive approach to this rather than simply whining about my score:

Perhaps just a little too background-busy for my tastes, and the white-balance seems a little off. (Possibly my monitor)

Mac Lip London Life
by gadion

Comment:
I've decided to comment on every shot in this challenge, since I'm sitting at 1 comments, and I'd rather try and take a positive approach to this rather than simply whining about my score:

One of the better product shots I've seen so far. The reliance on 'water drop' to boost a generic offering, however, is really getting old for me. Sadly, that's my own peeve, as I'm sure it's going nowhere.

Cover girl
by svava

Comment:
I've decided to comment on every shot in this challenge, since I'm sitting at 1 comments, and I'd rather try and take a positive approach to this rather than simply whining about my score:

Edgy, moody, and I like the connection to the viewer we're being given here. Very nicely lit and photographed.

The Mad Hatter
by LVicari

Comment:
I've decided to comment on every shot in this challenge, since I'm sitting at 1 comments, and I'd rather try and take a positive approach to this rather than simply whining about my score:

I'm a sucker for purple. A nicely done studio shot, but something in the model's look seems a little forced to me. It lacks, in my eyes, JUST that amount of emotion needed to really grip me. However, of course, DPC doesn't really look for that. I'd imagine this is doing fairly well.

The little Extra
by HeiSch

Comment:
I've decided to comment on every shot in this challenge, since I'm sitting at 1 comments, and I'd rather try and take a positive approach to this rather than simply whining about my score:

For my part, I'm not really sure what part of "fashion" this photo is trying to tell me. When I first look at it, I think "Holiday Decoration". It simply doesn't have a strong enough connection for me.

new linen line
by Vanagas

Comment:
I've decided to comment on every shot in this challenge, since I'm sitting at 1 comments, and I'd rather try and take a positive approach to this rather than simply whining about my score:

Some harsher lighting, and a lack of sharpness and detail, render this photo from a top performer, to a low-middle pack effort, in my mind. It's unique and humorous. Edgy in its own way, but simply lacks the technical reach to put it above.