40 Horses was too much
by F-StopBlues

Comment:
Hello. I am making a point on commenting on the photos that I rated a 2 or 3 in this challenge.

I gave this image a 2 for the following:

This is a DNMC from me. As much as I enjoy varied interpretations on challenges, for them to score well they have to be well thought out, clever, and at least thinly relative to the subject. This, in my opinion, is merely an action photo thrown in hoping to get some kind of wow factor vote, with the only relativity being the word "horse". To me, it's a cheap and quick way to enter a challenge for the sake of entering a challenge.

With this kind of choice, come chances. On this draw, you got a 2.

Horses
by Strikeslip

Comment:
Hello. I am making a point on commenting on the photos that I rated a 2 or 3 in this challenge.

I gave this image a 2 for the following:

There are far too many reasons. If you truly wish some constructive criticism on this photo when the challenge is over, contact me via PM.

Horsepower by Porsche
by basssman7

Comment:
Hello. I am making a point on commenting on the photos that I rated a 2 or 3 in this challenge.

I gave this image a 2 for the following:

For me, at this time, this is just too much of a DNMC. It's not even a real representation of horsepower (as thin a connection that is to horses) as it is just a gratuitous action shot. Heck, even hanging around and trying to get a nice shot of the Porsche logo would be more connective to this challenge. My feeling is that if you decide to take interpretation of a challenge this far, you deal with the consequences and one consequence is that you get a 2 from me today.

Sorry.

freespirits
by cutout

Comment:
Is this a photo of an existing work, or did you spend what looks to be an amazing amount of time cutting these out yourself?

Probability
by liberty

Comment:
How on earth did this finish so low. I kept clicking on the pages thinking, "where is that fantastic dice shot?"

Ouch.

Just goes to show I guess.

Toronto From Above - #3
by Shutter-For-Hire

Comment:
I really like this one. They really do look like models. I have some shots of Calgary from the Calgary Tower that I should try this on.

Toronto From Above - #7
by Shutter-For-Hire

Comment:
Ooo.. I forgot about this technique. Looking good.

Imperial Melboure
by vlado

Comment:
You mis-spelled melbourne. 1.


(just kidding)

Purple Light
by vtruan

Comment:
I admit it, I'm a sucker for lightning shots. This one isn't even all that great, but I scored it higher than many just because it's lightning.

*shakes fist*

The Headless Crawly Sand Monster
by colorcarnival

Comment:
Hehehe. Thanks for the chuckle.